Lou de Jager’s tackle on Thomas Ramos earned a permanent red card instead of the new 20-minute version, and Rassie Erasmus openly questioned why—especially after referee Angus Gardner classified it under a quietly updated “always illegal” category that many players say doesn’t fit the incident. With fans and legends furious over an “act of thuggery” label and Rugby laws looking more confused than ever, let us watch the video to see whether this was justice or another bureaucratic failure.